Achievements & Trophies
Harold Halibut Missable Achievements by Chapter
Which Harold Halibut achievements and notebook pages you can miss in each chapter, plus save-slot rules when using chapter select.

Save slot and chapter reload (read this first)
Harold Halibut has one save slot. After credits, pause → Load works as chapter select, with names like An Ordinary Day (1.1) through Epilogue on the chapter breakdown.
Pick any earlier sub-chapter and the game overwrites the file. Per the Steam guide, PSNProfiles, and TrueAchievements, the save snaps back to that checkpoint: PDA doodles, Buddy letters, cumulative TV or arcade minutes, optional NPC flags, and Slow Bro in-game time. You must play forward through the Epilogue before new progress saves. There is no backup slot.
That rule beats any single checklist line. Reload 1.3 for Managing Upwards and you repeat every later chapter unless you only want a partial replay.
How this guide counts missables
TrueAchievements tags seven achievements Missable: Rebel, Certificate of Participation, Managing Upwards, Aprés Ski, Busybody, Family Ties (And Uniforms), and Exchanger Arranger. PSNProfiles and similar guides still list about fourteen optional trophies when you skip side content.
The table lists tasks that fail if you leave a chapter too early. Multi-chapter achievements (Busybody, Family Ties, Postman) get one row per chapter that still needs a step that day. Totals feed the bar chart.
| Chapter | Missable achievement steps in this guide | Count |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rebel; Certificate of Participation; Managing Upwards; Aprés Ski; Busybody (1.3×2); Family Ties start; Neo-Luddite; The Plot Thickens (start TV) | 8 |
| 2 | Rubadubdub; Entertainment Onat Fan Club; O Captain! My Captain!; The Postman Always Rings Twice; Busybody (2.4) | 5 |
| 3 | — | 0 |
| 4 | Exchanger Arranger; Luke Warm; Insider Trading; Postman deliveries; Busybody (4.2 days); Family Ties (A Cappella) | 6 |
| 5 | — | 0 |
| 6 | — | 0 |
Notebook doodles add dozens more soft missables. All 71 names sit on all notebook notes. Highest-risk pages include #3 Chris in the Lounge, #10 brothers, #6 Skiing, and the Chapter 4.2 cluster.

Each bar counts table rows, not one row per achievement globally.
Chapter 1.1 — An Ordinary Day
- Rebel (Missable): After control returns in the All Water holding office, interact with the left exit three times before sitting with Felix. Talking through the intro first locks the attempt until you reload 1.1 and replay to Epilogue.
- Notebook #1: Research notes disagree whether the first doodle is All Water Intro (1.2) or All Water Secretary Office (1.1). Automatic either way if you do not reload past it.
Before you leave 1.1
- Trigger three exit attempts for Rebel before the Felix sit-down
- Ride the tube once for Tubular! (story)
Chapter 1.2 — The Hang of It
No TrueAchievements missable flags here, but notebook pages are easy to lose.
- Chris in the Lounge (#3): Talk through Chris's topics in the Lounge before the mandatory All Water buoy announcement sends you toward Agora.
- Fish feeding and Cyrus errands grant non-missable pages when you follow the main maintenance list.
Before you leave 1.2
- Exhaust Chris lounge dialogue before the Agora ticket activates
- Watch the buoy announcement with Chris
- Feed the lab fish after fetching food from Cyrus
Chapter 1.3 — The Solar Winds
The busiest optional day: several Missable achievements and nine notebook entries before sleep.
- Managing Upwards (Missable): After each blue-rock milestone (Tommy, Brigitte window, Cyrus printer line), return to Mareaux's lab and report. The game never forces the third visit. Neoseeker calls the trophy automatic; the Steam guide, PSNProfiles, and TrueAchievements disagree.
- Certificate of Participation (Missable): At Agora, find Buddy beside the theatre, wait for Chris, accept the jog, finish the minigame.
- Aprés Ski (Missable): Enter Slippie's shop, watch the ad, ride the mini slope. The shop is unavailable from Chapter 2 onward.
- Busybody (Missable): Stand at Gertrude's Bier Zone for two complete gossip scenes this day. Guides differ on whether Neoseeker's single mention understates the second 1.3 listen.
- Family Ties (Missable): Secretary chain 17→8→24→8→17 (TrueAchievements once wrote Secretary 28 instead of 24).
- The Plot Thickens: Begin Lounge TV watching toward ten total minutes (finish before Chapter 6).
- A Winner Is You!: Two minutes on Rapid Fly Zone Force (cumulative).
- Optional notebook pages: Rafi at Intercom Oasis, Fish Hut, Coco on Captain's Deck, brothers note, etc.
Before you leave 1.3
- Report to Mareaux after Tommy, after Brigitte, and after Cyrus steps
- Accept and finish Buddy's jog
- Complete Slippie ski slope and first graffiti clean
- Hear both bar gossip scenes
- Finish secretary brother visits the same day
- Start TV and arcade timers toward cumulative trophies
Chapter 1.4 — The Sample
- Neo-Luddite (guide missable): When Brigitte messages that the sample is ready, go to Energy District and speak to her before picking up the sample in the lab.
- Busybody (Missable): Third gossip segment at the bar.
- Cyrus Plan (#16) and Stranger Danger (#17) depend on optional Central Station dialogue (1.4 vs 1.3 placement disputed).
Before you leave 1.4
- Visit Brigitte in Energy District before lab sample pickup
- Catch the third Bier Zone gossip
- Talk to Cyrus during the sample day if you need his notebook page
Chapter 1.5–1.6
Story-heavy; no TA missable flags. Shaft and pump sequences add automatic notebook pages (#19–20) if you do not reload away from them.
Chapter 2.1 — The Creature from the Sea
Complete optional tasks before giving Fishy the Sunny replacements; pipe locks after that main step.
- Rubadubdub (guide missable): Social District second room shower Announcer.
- Entertainment Onat Fan Club: Watch the formal performance (storage progress required).
- O Captain! My Captain! begins multi-day Zoya visits.
- The Postman Always Rings Twice: First Buddy letter at Utility Post Office.
- Family Ties: Warren Water Wieners intro.
- Clean Machine (2/2) graffiti.
- Notebook pages: Announcer, Buddy, Graffiti, Mysterious Door, Secret Guest automatic after story beats.
Before you leave 2.1
- Clear remaining Lab graffiti
- Rubadubdub shower scene before Fishy hand-in
- Read first Buddy letter
- Watch Onat's stage show
- Start Captain Zoya optional chain
Chapter 2.2–2.3
- Warren and brothers (#26–27): Visit Warren, then secretaries again; guides split whether this belongs to 2.1 or 2.2.
- Bacteria Party (#29): After medicating Fishy, help Brigitte's second rock analysis in Energy District (Steam guide once labeled Social District).
- Postman (2/9–3/9): Additional letters before dinner with Brigitte.
Before you leave 2.3
- Finish Sunny medicine and Brigitte's second analysis for Bacteria Party
- Read any unread Buddy letters before the chapter jumps
Chapter 2.4 — All Water Conspiracy
- Busybody (Missable): Fourth gossip before chasing Coco / Rafi errands.
Before you leave 2.4
- Listen to Zim and Alon gossip before leaving for Rafi
Chapters 2.5–3
No achievement missables called out in walkthrough facts beyond continuing TV time. Chapter 3 cave exploration grants ritual and library doodles if you speak to every Flumylym NPC in 3.2.
Chapter 4.1 — The Expedition
Buddy's funeral is mandatory. Exchanger Arranger order varies: Neoseeker allows some exchange chats after the funeral; TrueAchievements says to finish NPC banter before desk letters. Steam comments say letters-first still works. Treat order as disputed.
Chapter 4.2 — Analysis of the Crack
Highest density day pair.
- Exchanger Arranger (Missable): Talk to every exchange NPC (Tommy, cave Flumylym, Chris, Major, Frank, Sunny, Warren, Secretary 17, and others) before advancing past optional letters.
- Insider Trading: Warren stall relocation.
- Luke Warm: Slippie adapter in Brigitte's Energy office.
- Postman: Up to five deliveries plus Buddy's Final Race trigger.
- Busybody (Missable): Fifth and sixth gossip scenes; TrueAchievements places both on day 2 of 4.2 back-to-back, while PSNProfiles spreads into 4.3.
- Notebook cluster (#45–52): Exchange booths, Sunny cupcakes, coffee Flumylym, Filter Frankie, and more before Join the Gang.
Before you leave 4.2
- Finish every exchange NPC conversation
- Move Warren's stand and help Slippie install the adapter
- Deliver outstanding Buddy mail
- Hear both day-2 bar gossip topics
Chapter 4.3 — Refining the Plan
- Join the Gang locks out unfinished mail or exchange tasks per the Steam guide.
- Notebook pages Dizzy Fish, Singing Particles, and Energy Container come from mandatory experiment scenes.
Before you leave 4.3
- Confirm Postman and Exchanger Arranger trophies fired before cave gang meeting
Chapter 4.4 — Final Preparations
- Family Ties (Missable): Optional barbershop A Cappella after the crying secretary stall scene. Some guides instead mark Warren's Gourmet beat in Epilogue as the finale; sources contradict.
Before you leave 4.4
- Watch the four brothers acapella if Family Ties is still open
Chapters 5–6
Walkthrough consensus: no missable achievements beyond story notebooks Chasing Dragons and the Chapter 6 auto pages. Sub-chapter placement of The Core doodles differs between Neoseeker (6.3) and Steam (6.2).
Epilogue
No new Missable-flag achievements here, but five notebook doodles (Ancient Onat, Hot Dog Contest, Frank Jr., Captain Zoya, Same Old CEO) belong before goodbye to Weeoo. Grab Same Old last if Forschergeist fails to pop. Slow Bro needs 15+ in-game hours before credits if it is not already earned.
See the full achievement list for unlock text and the trophy guide for PlayStation tiering.
Sources and last check
- TrueAchievements achievement list — seven official Missable tags
- TrueAchievements walkthrough part 2 — chapter reload and save-slot rules
- PSNProfiles trophy guide — optional trophy count and Busybody placement
- Steam guide by sadcat.jpg — day-by-day missable deadlines
- Neoseeker walkthrough 1.1 — Rebel timing; Managing Upwards disagreement
Last checked 2026-11-17.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important rule before using chapter select?
Pause → Load picks a sub-chapter and overwrites your only save. Notebook pages, letters, cumulative TV or arcade time, and Slow Bro's in-game clock snap back to that checkpoint until you reach Epilogue again.
How many missable achievements are there?
TrueAchievements tags seven achievements Missable. PSNProfiles groups fourteen chapter-tied optional trophies that you can skip by rushing main tasks only.
Can you miss Forschergeist without missing an achievement earlier?
Forschergeist is a collectable trophy for 71 notebook doodles, not a Missable flag. Individual doodles still expire when you sleep or advance days if you skip the conversation that creates them.
Does Managing Upwards unlock automatically?
Neoseeker's table calls it automatic at the end of 1.3, but the Steam guide, PSNProfiles, and TrueAchievements require three manual reports to Jeanne Mareaux during the blue-rock errand.
When must Buddy's mail chain finish?
Guides place the last deliveries before Chapter 4.3 Join the Gang. Missing a letter forces a reload from the earliest sub-chapter where that letter is still available.